Proud hosts of this Indigenous-led water quality monitoring program!

Introduction 

Athabasca River Water Quality Monitoring Program

Our water monitoring program began in June of 2022. The initial phase if this program

collects basic but key water quality measurements. As the program grows in the future more

types of measurements will be taken. Keepers has the instrumentation to determine these

key water quality conditions:

1. Water Oxygen Levels

2. Temperature

3. pH

4. Conductivity

5. Salinity

6. TDS

1. Water Oxygen Levels

The term used by biologists is “dissolved oxygen” (DO), which refers to how much oxygen

gas is in the river or lake water. This oxygen gas is needed for fish and all types of aquatic life

to survive. Dissolved Oxygen can tell us a lot about water quality.

Fast moving water, such as a mountain river or a large river usually has more oxygen.

Oxygen enters a river or lake mainly from the air above. The action of lake waves or stream

rapids will pull in air and oxygen.

What is a healthy oxygen level in a river or Lake? 10 ppm (or mg/L) in water or above is a

healthy level oxygen for fish and other organisms. Healthy dissolved oxygen levels vary for

each organism, but levels around 8-9 mg/L will support all life. Most aquatic life will die at

levels around 2 or 3 mg/L. Fish need higher oxygen levels than other smaller aquatic

species. Trout need a minimum of six parts per million (6 ppm) oxygen for good growth and

survival. They prefer colder water and will die in warm water with levels of DO consistently

lower than 6 ppm. The highest possible river oxygen level in Alberta is 14 mg/L most likely to

be found in rapids in cold mountain streams.

There are numerous ways industry pollution can cause a drop in water oxygen levels

2. Water Temperature

Water temperature is a critical indicator of water health in a river or lake. Warm water will

cause oxygen levels to drop which will stress fish. Cooler water temperatures usually indicate

healthier water. Cold water has the ability to hold more oxygen than warm water because at

higher temperatures oxygen gas molecules move faster and escape more easily from the

water surface.

River water temperatures that are too high can kill fish due to a condition called hypoxia (too

little oxygen). There are a few reasons why water temperatures could get too high. They

include low water levels and climate change which brings with it higher air and source water

temperatures. Another big concern with northern lakes is the loss of ice cover too early in the

spring. This results in warmer water in the summer months and a risk of fish die-off due to low

oxygen levels. Ice reflects about 90% of the sun heat energy while open water will absorb

more than 90% of the heat energy. Wind is the wildcard factor in lakes, because strong winds

can replenish oxygen due to wave action pulling in oxygen.

High water temperature will also accelerate the harmful chemical reactions of pollution and

aquatic organisms will feel the impact more rapidly. Cold water can slow impacts of pollution

but the pollution will stay longer.

Over the seasons a river will experience dramatic differences in water temperature; from 0.2

deg C in the late winter to 16 deg C. or more in the late summer. These higher temperature

may not be a problem if they are are short lasting. Continuous temperature monitoring

provides valuable data for long-term analysis of water quality trends, especially as they now

relate to the accelerating climate crisis. With this information local water managers can make

more informed decisions about water allocations, ecosystem management, and other needed

actions.

3. pH

pH refers to the acid or alkaline quality of water. The pH scale ranges from 0 to 14, with 7

indicating neutrality. Water with a pH less than 7 is considered acidic, while water with a pH

greater than 7 is alkaline. Northern lakes and rivers are often at a pH state of 8 or slightly

above. This is the healthy normal for aquatic life.

pH can impact the availability of nutrients, and the survival of aquatic organisms. A change in

pH from previous readings can indicate the presence of pollutants or contaminants, which

can have adverse effects on the environment and human health. Acidic waters can harm fish

by interfering with their gills' ability to take up oxygen, causing death or other harmful

impacts. Usually a low pH in most industrially active areas is caused by sulfates. This refers

to sulfur based compounds which are present in large quantities in mined ores in the coal

and/ tar sand industries. Low pH will cause heavy metals that are present in water to be more

toxic.

Acid rain refers to air pollution such as sulfur dioxide (SO2) from an industrial smoke stack

which mixes in the air far away from the source and falls to the ground and on lakes when it is

washed out of the sky by rain. Over many years this acid rain will drop the pH of a lake to the

point where aquatic life cannot survive. This dangerous pH level is below 6.

4. Electrical Conductivity

Conductivity is a measure of how well a substance in water conducts electricity. It is a key

indicator of mineral or metal pollution in water. This sensor measures the dissolved

ions of these types of pollutants along with naturally occurring ions.

The conductivity of water increases with the increased concentration of dissolved salts,

minerals, and metal ions. These substances can seriously affect the water quality and the

health of aquatic ecosystems.

In our field testing we can immediately determine if there is the presence of excessive

problematic ions. In order to determine what the substance is exactly requires a lab test. The

conductivity reading gives a warning of a problem if it exists or is increasing in a particular

site. This test is useful for learning about the extent of local pollution sources or spill

incidents. Conductivity is also affected by temperature, so the warmer the water, the higher

the conductivity.

Normal levels are between 0 -200 uS/cm(milliSiemens per centimetre) and will be higher when

water temperatures are high.

5. Salinity

The conductivity probe in our water monitoring equipment also gathers data on salinity or salt

levels in the water.* Salinity is the dissolved salt content of a body of water. It is a strong

contributor to conductivity and helps determine the health of a body of water.

Salts can be toxic to freshwater plants and animals and can make water unsafe for drinking,

irrigation and livestock watering. High salinity levels can kill all life in the boreal aquatic

ecosystem, but most organisms and plants can manage low salt levels. Salts interfere with

most life metabolism functions and consistent low levels will create chronic health impacts to

fish and other organisms.

Increased salinity will also cause a reduction of the oxygen holding capacity of river or lake

water. It is easy to see how the the combined impacts of climate change and elevated salinity

can seriously harm an aqueous ecosystem.

Salinity is a significant concern in the lower Athabasca region due to the fact that tailings

pond liquids are very high in salts and are leaking into the groundwater which flows into the

Athabasca River.

Normal levels of salinity for northern rivers is 0.4 part per thousand (ppt) for most of the year.

*Conductivity measurements, along with temperature, also allow for salinity values to be calculated through

algorithms.

6. TDS: Total Dissolved Solids

Total dissolved solids is a measure of the dissolved combined content of all mineral and

organic substances present in a river in molecular, ionized, or micro-granular suspended form.

TDS in river or lake water originate from natural sources, sewage, urban and agricultural run-

off, and industrial wastewater.

A low number, less that 200 ppm suggests high quality water. Most drinking water standards

allow up to 500 ppm TDS. Good tasting spring water with its naturally occurring minerals will

have 200 to 400 ppm TDS.

TDS are often measured in parts per million.(ppm)

Keepers of the Water, Indigenous Led Water Monitoring Summary Reports


Other Relevant Water Quality reports for the Athabasca River;

Keepers of the Water partnered with GW Solutions Inc. to collate water quality data for the Athabasca River dating back to 2017 and as recent as 2022. 

The conclusions and recommendations are as follows;

CONCLUSIONS  

Based on our assessment of available information, we draw the following conclusions: 

1. The oil sands activities have had adverse impacts on the water quality of the Athabasca River over time. This can be  confirmed with increasing concentrations of sulfate and chloride, typical indicators of human disturbance. 

2. Chloride in the Athabasca River clearly indicates an increase in concentration from a median of 4 mg/l upstream of  the tailing’s ponds to medians of 16.3 mg/l, 20.3 mg/l, and 33 mg/l, for sections at the right of the first and second  series of tailing ponds, and downstream of the oil sands area, respectively.  

3. Considering the availability and adequate of some of the water quality parameters along the Athabasca River,  some of the dissolved metals concentrations such as boron, lithium, strontium, and uranium show an increasing  trend downstream of Athabasca River whereas there is a decreasing trend at the same time frame at the monitoring  stations located upstream of the lower Athabasca River. 

4. Several metals and other parameters such as total arsenic, total lead, total mercury, total cadmium, total chromium,  total aluminum, total iron and total manganese, fluoride, dissolved sulfide, pH, temperature, TDS and color have a  record of exceedances of Guidelines for Canadian Drinking Water Quality. This is predominantly observed  downstream of the tailing ponds and oil sands operations. 

5. Several parameters such as pH and alkalinity, dissolved oxygen, dissolved iron, dissolved aluminum, dissolved  sulfide, total mercury, total cadmium, total copper, total arsenic, total lead and chloride residual have exceeded  thresholds of the Guidelines for the protection of aquatic life. Similarly, this is predominantly observed at the  downstream of the tailing ponds and oil sands operations. 

 RECOMMENDATIONS 

1. We recommend continuing searching for data sources and updating the platform with not only more data from  different sources but also adding recent data from the already identified data sources. For instance, we have  recently received data from Alberta Environment prior completion of this report that we would like to integrate into  the Platform and further assess the results.

2. We recommend allocating more resources and time in interpreting the existing information, in particular identifying  parameters that show similar trends to better connect the presence of certain elements with sources. It is important  to confirm or refute the presence of certain parameters with potential natural sources. 

3. We recommend the First Nations of the Athabasca Region approach the oil sands industry partners to request that  water quality data collected by the industry be shared with them as this information describes the status of the  indigenous land and water. 

4. We recommend conducting an in-person workshop to present the tool to members of Keepers of the Water who  could benefit from its capability. 

Report

Keepers of the Water Summary of Gilles Wendling

Report

GW Solutions Inc.